skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Fracking
Safe Chemicals
Defending the Clean Air Act

Pete Altman’s Blog

Scholastic Steps Into the Chamber of Hypocrisy

Pete Altman

Posted October 20, 2010 in Curbing Pollution

Tags:
, , ,
Share | | |

Politico reports that the Scholastic company – producer and distributor of a wide range of educational products to our nation’s school systems – has teamed up with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce on an “educational” program about US energy consumption.

In the article, entitled “Chamber: Worry about energy regulations, kids”, Politico writes:

“The U.S. Chamber of Commerce wants middle school students to consider what would happen if government regulations shut down the coal industry or another domestic energy source.

The question is part of a teaching guide the group plans to distribute to roughly 100,000 classrooms across the country as part of its “Shedding Light on Energy” program with educational publisher Scholastic Inc.

“What do you think could happen if one of our energy sources was suddenly unavailable (e.g., power plant maintenance, government curb on production, etc.)?” the guide asks.

Chamber officials maintain that there is no “hidden agenda” behind the question or the educational outreach effort in general. But given the current political climate surrounding the Environmental Protection Agency’s efforts to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, the group’s direct involvement in public school education is expected to make environmentalists and like-minded progressives uncomfortable.”

Actually, the fact that Scholastic is using its wholesome name to traffic the US Chamber of Commerce’s pollution-friendly propaganda should be alarming to anyone with kids in the public school system (I have two.) In fact, the hypocrisy embedded in the US Chamber's involvement in producing education materials on energy for kids is downright shocking.

What makes the US Chamber such an inappropriate partner in child education?

One reason is that the Chamber’s information is extremely one-sided. It neglects to mention the public health, environmental and national security consequences of our reliance on dirty energy sources. The coal and oil which supplies a great deal of our energy also creates extraordinary amounts of air, water and soil pollution, and of course are primarily responsible for the warming of our planet. Our addiction to oil makes the US vulnerable to oil-producing nations that wish us harm. These are consequences that today’s kids will have to deal with as tomorrow’s leaders.

It is puzzling that Scholastic is willing to align itself with incomplete and biased material, especially since its own “Kids’ Environmental Report Card” ranks global warming and other pollution issues as serious challenges kids want to take on.

But even more puzzling is why Scholastic would partner with an organization that has so little regard for the health and welfare of our nation’s kids. The US Chamber of Commerce has a long track record of opposing common-sense public health protections, especially those intended to protect our children. A few examples:

  • The US Chamber has been a consistent opponent of efforts to reduce mercury pollution. Mercury is a dangerous neurotoxin that interferes with children’s brain development and can cause severe learning disorders. Unborn children are especially vulnerable - according to the EPA “Impacts on cognitive thinking, memory, attention, language, and fine motor and visual spatial skills have been seen in children exposed to methylmercury in the womb.”

    Despite the dangers, the Chamber’s answer has been to rely on misinformation as tool to oppose stricter standards.  

    So …the US Chamber of Commerce, which opposes measures that would limit our children’s exposure to mercury, which is known to cause serious learning disorders, is producing educational materials for kids?
  • The US Chamber is currently opposing tighter standards to reduce smog or ground-level ozone, a widespread pollution problem that responsible for a range of health effects to which children are especially vulnerable. Smog pollution contributes to thousands of premature mortalities every year and is a known cause and trigger for respiratory problems like asthma, a disease that is spreading most rapidly in children younger than 17 years old, who also account for the highest overall rates of asthma among the population at large.

    The US EPA is working to tighten standards for this kind of pollution in order to prevent as many as 12,000 deaths per year and thousands of other effects, but the US Chamber is trying to block these crucial health protections.

    Making this even more ironic is the fact that the tighter standards the Chamber is trying to block would reduce by over 2 million the number of days of school kids miss due to air-pollution related illnesses. Hey, how are the kids supposed to read the Chamber’s communiqués if they are gasping for breath in the emergency room?
  • The US Chamber has urged Congress to oppose efforts to ban dangerous chemicals commonly found in children’s toys. Phthalates are chemicals used in many common consumer products, including as softeners of plastic children's toys -- like a rubber ducky. As NRDC’s Sarah Janssen explains,  

“Some phthalates are hormone-disrupting chemicals that interfere with production of the male hormone testosterone, and have been associated with reproductive abnormalities.”

Yet the US Chamber opposes protecting children from these dangerous chemicals, explaining in one letter to Congress that “Manufacturers would be forced to use more expensive alternatives that may unfairly subject them to additional safety and legal liability concerns.”

Scholastic’s decision to partner with the US Chamber is all the more disappointing because it does include environmental education resources (full disclosure, including some links to NRDC.)

So what can you do about this? You can let Scholastic’s CEO and executives know that you are concerned about the partnership with the US Chamber and ask them to stop the program. Here’s how you can reach them (and a sample note is below.)

Write these top Scholastic executives:

If you prefer snail mail:

Scholastic
557 Broadway
New York, NY 10012

Or a phone call:
(212) 343-6100

SAMPLE LETTER

Dear Mr. Robinson and Scholastic,

I am writing to express my concern about Scholastic’s “Shedding Light on Energy” partnership with the US Chamber of Commerce.

The materials that have been made public fail to shed much light on the critical consequences of our energy use and fail to challenge students to think of creative solutions to our energy problems. They also appear to neglect topics that Scholastic's own "Kids' Environmental Report Card" identifies as important.

In addition, the US Chamber has a long record of opposing efforts to protect children from dangerous chemicals and pollutants like mercury, smog and phthalates.

Kids today are will be our leaders tomorrow. We owe them – and ourselves – better than what the US Chamber materials have to offer.

I urge you to end the partnership with the US Chamber, and to recall and recycle all materials printed and distributed in association with it.

Please let me know what you plan to do.

Sincerely,

Your name, address and zip

Share | | |

Comments

Dan MoutalOct 20 2010 09:41 PM

Who is advocating making dirty energy "suddenly unavailable"?

No one. What people are advocating for is to phase out dirty energy, and replace it with clean energy.

Big difference

David MartinOct 21 2010 10:18 AM

You have his email correct per a pres release I found from Scholastic

http://www.commercialfreechildhood.org/pressreleases/scholastic.htm

Judy Gatton PratsOct 21 2010 10:49 AM

Do not try to brainwash our children. Teach them to think critically; do not teach them to think just like you and your corporate sponsors.

Jess LeberOct 21 2010 11:36 AM

Thanks for this info, Pete! I just made it easy for anyone who wants to write a letter to scholastic...here is an online petition that will send an email to the targets he suggests.

http://environment.change.org/petitions/view/tell_scholastic_dont_publish_dirty_energy_educational_guides

Jess LeberOct 21 2010 11:47 AM

Oh, sure. Good idea. I'll add a link now!

I also wrote a post about the issue, in which I linked back to NRDC, but had forgotten to put it in the petition.
http://environment.change.org/petitions/view/tell_scholastic_dont_publish_dirty_energy_educational_guides

Danielle EnglishOct 22 2010 05:42 PM

Thank you for this post - I just sent an email, and am shocked that this is happening! I remember adoring Scholastic as a child. It worries me that kids today, who probably also love Scholastic for their kid-reading needs, are potentially learning this stuff.

Great post!

Danica LovingsOct 26 2010 09:34 AM

I am an employee of Scholastic AND a sustaining member of NRDC. I am really surprised that an organization I’ve contributed to and believed in for so long would take such a strong position against a company that has put the broadening of students’ minds at the forefront for decades.

The Scholastic Credo closes with this statement: Good citizens may honestly differ on important public questions. We believe that all sides of the issues of our times should be fairly discussed — with deep respect for facts and logical thinking — in classroom magazines, books, and other educational materials used in schools and homes.

By including the prompt “What would happen if one of our domestic energy sources was shut down?” in their “Shedding Light on Energy” materials, Scholastic is helping students explore all possibilities and think critically. The program’s materials are comprised of facts about the workings of our energy-dependent infrastructure. These are all facts that students are required to learn in order to meet state standards in science and math.

Helping students gather information from multiple sources, analyze the facts and think critically is something Scholastic strives to support through our many educational programs and materials. And Scholastic has hundreds of books and curriculum supplements that explore themes about sustainability, global warming, taking care of the earth, clean energy, and more. We will continue to present students with the facts and provide teachers with the tools to lead discussions in their classrooms that allow all points of view to be presented so our students learn to think critically now and throughout their lives.

Comments are closed for this post.

About

Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit NRDC.org.

Feeds: Pete Altman’s blog

Feeds: Stay Plugged In