skip to main content

Natural Resources Defense Council

Switchboard

Pete Altman's Blog

Obama Is Not The Spokesperson-In-Chief For Clean Coal

Obama Is Not The Spokesperson-In-Chief For Clean Coal

We were going to ignore the latest nonsense from the American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity (ACCCE) until we saw this week's Bloomberg story:  "Clean-Coal Debate Pits Al Gore's Group Against Obama, Peabody."

In the article, Bloomberg cites a recent ACCCE ad blitz as a sign that President Barack Obama is in the corner of the coal industry when it comes to "clean coal technology."

Score one point for ACCCE, which has been peddling that malarkey for weeks now.  And deduct one point from the truth, which is not something that ACCCE appears to care very much about.

The chances are pretty good that you've seen this ACCCE TV ad at least once in recent days.  It's the one where ACCCE uses sound bites from an Obama stump speech delivered last September 9th in Lebanon, VA.   (That's the campaign appearance that previously made history for the candidate's comparison of something to make-up applied to the face of a certain barnyard animal that in no way resembles Sarah Palin.)  

You can see extended excerpts from the Obama speech courtesy of the Roanoke Times.

There's just one problem here: ACCCE couldn't resist taking liberties with the Obama speech.   In fact, it's such a misleading depiction of what Obama said that it deserves to be enshrined in the misleading advertising hall of shame.

Don't take my word for it.  Watch the ACCCE ad first here and then go to the second video excerpt from the Lebanon, VA., stump speech. (Fast forward the video excerpt to 01:27.)  You will find the final problems when you compare the ACCCE ad to the Obama speech:

  • 1. When Obama talked about "clean energy" first, he talked about wind and solar - not coal.
  • 2. When Obama talked about "clean coal technology," he made it very clear that it doesn't exist today. In fact, he compares what is needed to get the technology to the President John F. Kennedy's famous challenge to the nation to "put a man on the moon in 10 years." This was certainly no ringing endorsement of where the coal industry is today on clean coal technology - and that is nowhere!
  • 3. When Obama talks about "5 million new jobs," he is taking about "clean energy," not coal, as the ACCCE TV spot implies. In fact, the ACCCE ad precedes the Obama jobs sound bite with a screenshot that says "clean coal ... creating jobs". And that is what - in Ethics 101 - is called lying. If you are more charitable than me and want to call it misleading, that's your call. Either way, ACCCE is distorting what happened to make it look incorrectly like Obama is their #1 Fan.

Of course, other industries have attempted in recent weeks to hijack Obama as their spokesperson.  But it's hard to imagine anything worse than being shanghaied by an industry that is as dirty as coal ... and one that is working in direct opposition to Obama's goals on addressing global warming.

No wonder the Administration is looking into cracking down on the unauthorized use of the President's image for commercial and issue advocacy purposes.   After what ACCCE has done with its new advertising campaign, who can blame the White House for not wanting to be made the unwilling spokesperson for an indefensible cause.

Tags:
ACCCE, dirtycoal

(bookmark or email this entry)

Comments

Dave MooreFeb 9 2009 04:31 PM

I believe that the position of NRDC like that of Pres Obama on clean coal and its place in the energy mix is unclear. I don't see any firm call for a moratorium on new coal plants in the US until they have CO2 capture. I also don't see a call for closing the older coal fired plants that do not meet mercury and SO@ health guidelines.
Also reading about the NRDC work in China is very inspiring, but seems to consider new coal expansion inevitable. I don't believe any work on energy alternatives will mitigate the climate damage caused by such a long term comittment to coal electricity in the developing world. There must be a limit to coal burning expansion or the world is condemned to be a very different place.

Comments are closed for this post.

We close comments on a blog post when it's clear the conversation has moved on -- click on the tags (above) or on our homepage to see if we've got fresh news and views on this post's topic.

Clean Energy Common Sense

OnEarth: NRDC's award-winning magazine

Citizen journalism from the OnEarth magazine website

Day Five of No Impact Week: Lights Out
by Solvie Karlstrom
The Not-So-Badness of Guides to Green Living
by Emily Gertz
No Impact Week Day Four: Foreign Foods
by Solvie Karlstrom

Read more

Fresh Conversation

Feeds: Stay Plugged In