skip to main content

Natural Resources Defense Council

Switchboard

Pete Altman's Blog

NBC's Brian Williams: Clean coal is "wishful thinking."

NBC's Brian Williams: Clean coal is

Kudos to Brian Williams and Anne Thompson of NBC for taking a closer look at whether coal can actually be called clean. Earlier this week they aired a story (thanks to Josh Dorner at Sierra Club for flagging it) looking into the coal industry's favorite claim. Brian Williams' take? "Wishful thinking."

Why is there no such thing as clean coal? Get the dirt on coal at NRDC's Coal in a Changing Climate page, including this detailed coal issue paper.

Tags:
brianwilliams, cleancoal, coal, NBC

(bookmark or email this entry)

Comments

David with ACCCENov 20 2008 09:11 AM

Anchorman Brian Williams began the report by calling clean coal “an oxymoron,” failing to acknowledge the suite of technologies that have been developed over the last 30 years to remove harmful emissions from coal-based power plants.

These technologies have already made coal a cleaner energy resource—overall our plants are 70 percent cleaner today than they were in the 1970s based on regulated emissions per unit of energy produced. And with new advances in technology, we’re looking at a future in which coal will meet America’s growing electricity needs with little to no emissions of the pollutants regulated by federal and state clean air laws.

However, the NBC team redeemed themselves a bit by traveling to Germany to profile the country’s $100 million pilot carbon capture and sequestration plant, which eliminates 95 percent of carbon dioxide from power plant emissions and buries them underground.

NBC also noted the lack of U.S. funding for pilot plants here in America, cutting to a researcher from the MIT Energy Initiative who said, “I believe we have really no time to waste in pursuing a whole set of low-carbon technology options.”

In the end, NBC showed America that carbon capture and sequestration is not only possible, but necessary in order to utilize our most abundant, affordable energy source, and that it’s time to support the funding of the next generation of clean coal technologies.

Peter AltmanNov 20 2008 12:27 PM

David - thanks for reading. I found it easier to respond to your comments with a new post which is here: http://switchboard.nrdc.org/blogs/paltman/all_the_coal_money_in_1.html

Regarding CCS, NRDC believes that no coal plant should be built that doesn't capture its carbon dioxide. But even that won't make coal clean. See David Hawkin's testimony for further elucidation: http://commerce.senate.gov/public/_files/HawkinsSenCommerceapr0908final.pdf

Comments are closed for this post.

OnEarth: NRDC's award-winning magazine

Citizen journalism from the OnEarth magazine website

What's Happening: USDA Organic Called Out, and more
by Ben Jervey
No Room For Tigers, and People
by Charles Annenberg Weingarten
NYC Looks Forward With the Help of a New Generation of Urban Planners
by Kris French

Read more

Fresh Conversation

Feeds: Stay Plugged In