skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Fracking
Safe Chemicals
Defending the Clean Air Act

Kaid Benfield’s Blog

Revitalizing Over-the-Rhine (Part 2: building on the neighborhood’s assets)

Kaid Benfield

Posted June 8, 2009 in Environmental Justice, Green Enterprise, Living Sustainably, Solving Global Warming

Tags:
, , , , , , , ,
Share | | |

Last week I wrote the first installment of my miniseries about Cincinnati's remarkable Over-the-Rhine neighborhood.  As I wrote then, this distinct and historic quarter adjacent to Cincinnati's downtown is full of promise but bears considerable scars from decades of disinvestment, having declined in population from over 40,000 at its peak to under 10,000 today.  Much of its splendid 19th-century architecture has suffered serious decay, and it has had all the problems of poverty and crime that plagued too many of our inner-city neighborhoods in the late 20th century.  The good news, though, is that I believe OTR can become a nationally significant model of inclusive, green revitalization if everything falls into place.

    a revitalizing street in OTR (c2009 FK Benfield)  Italianate architecture in OTR (by: Ed from Ohio, creative commons license))

One of the main reasons that I have much hope for Over-the-Rhine is that it has some tremendous neighborhood assets to build a recovery upon, starting not just with historic architecture but also with a resilient existing community of residents.  My impression when visiting last month was that, poverty and problems notwithstanding, OTR feels like a real neighborhood and a real community.  It will be critical that the neighborhood's restoration includes these residents at every step.  As the city's comprehensive plan for the neighborhood notes:

"The committed residents and businesses that remain in the neighborhood today will be the backbone of the revitalization . . . [But] Making people feel respected, welcomed, valued and connected is a tall order."

No doubt.  But the success of Old North St. Louis in approaching a very similar situation gives me a lot of hope that this can be done in the right way.

Let's continue with a close look at OTR's geography.  As I noted last week, the neighborhood sits right between the central business district and the uptown University district, the region's two largest concentrations of employment.  That's a terrific location, one that all the current urban trends suggest is highly favorable to recovery.  Moreover,  the neighborhood's 19th-century architectural scale, along with block sizes manageable for humans as well as for cars, make it ideal for walking. 

Over-the-Rhine (underlying image by Google Earth, particulars by me) 

In the satellite image above, three of OTR's most striking physical assets are marked with (virtual) push-pins.  In the center-north, the yellow pin marks the historic and lively Findlay Market, Ohio's oldest.  In the south, the blue pin identifies lovely Washington Park, with its old bandstand.  And just to the west of the park is the fuchsia pin, marking the location of Cincinnati's enormous baroque Music Hall, where the symphony and opera perform.  Look closely (or click on the image for an enlargement) and you can also see marks identifying various churches, schools, parks, markets, and eateries sprinkled around the neighborhood.  (Google Earth is amazing; I had a lot of fun doing this.)  We'll get to the light blue lines later in the post.

  Findlay Market (c2009 FK Benfield)  inside the Market (by: FindlayMarket.org) 

The Findlay Market is an old-fashioned public market that has been in continuous operation since 1858.  According to its website, the Market is open year-round Tuesday through Sunday, hosting about two dozen local and regional merchants selling meat, fish, poultry, produce, flowers, cheese, and ethnic foods. In addition, on Saturdays and Sundays from April to November Findlay also hosts a farmers market, dozens of additional vendors, street performers, and special events.  The website claims that it "routinely attracts perhaps the most socially, economically, racially, and ethnically diverse crowds found anywhere in Cincinnati," and I don't doubt it. 

  taking a break (by: FindlayMarket.org)  the Market circa 1900 (by: FindlayMarket.org)

That the Market has remained economically healthy and is only becoming more robust is a great sign for the neighborhood.  The website contains all the latest news and a wonderful short video that gives you a great sense of both the Market's history and its current place in the community (highly recommended).

  Washington Park in OTR (c2009 FK Benfield)  site plan for the updated park (by: City of Cincinnati)

My own walk through OTR began with Washington Park.  I found the park, filled with trees and neighborhood-sized public spaces, to be only slightly worn for the wear.  Kevin Lemaster writes on Building Cincinnati that the park will be getting its own renovation, expanding to the north, and getting an underground garage.  I'm not sure why such a walkable, under-populated and transit-served neighborhood needs a new garage, but expansion onto what is now paved former school property is a great idea.  I think the current park is pretty darn nice, so I hope the renovation is done sensitively.  (I have no reason to believe it won't be.)  I know lots of neighborhoods, city and suburban both, that would love to have a park like this.

  Washington Park bandstand (by: City of Cincinnati)  only part of the Cincinnati Music Hall (c2009 FK Benfield)

There's a photo of the park's old bandstand just above, with the amazing Cincinnati Music Hall in the background.  To the right is a separate photo of the Music Hall, which sits just across the street from the northwest corner of the park.  Finished in 1878, the Hall's main auditorium seats 3500 people, and also includes a 20,000-square-foot ballroom, used for both performances and meetings, as well as assorted other gathering places. 

One has to be struck by the contrast afforded by the presence of such a bastion of highbrow culture in a neighborhood beset with poverty, but I see the Hall as a huge plus, keeping OTR connected to its larger region and important potential sources of investment.  Not to mention the architecture.  Go to the website of the Society for the Preservation of Music Hall for some wonderful old pictures and a video of the installation of the Mighty Wurlitzer organ in the ballroom.

      church of St Francis Seraph, "The Heart of OTR 1859-2009" (c2009 FK Benfield)    Nast Trinity UMC, 1888 (via Samuel Hannaford scrapbook, cop. Betty Ann Smiddy)

Those three are big-time assets for a revitalizing neighborhood, or any neighborhood.  And I was also struck by the number of churches in Over-the-Rhine.  While I was told that the neighborhood's population decline has meant that not all of them are still operating, many of them are.  In many places institutions of faith can be important community building blocks, and I think their presence is another plus for OTR.

To top it all off, remember the light blue lines on the Google Earth image above?  They mark the likely route of Cincinnati's almost-real new streetcar, which if all goes as planned will run continuously through the neighborhood.  click to view slide show on the Cincinnati streetcar (by: City of Cincinnati)Earlier this year, the city council approved the streetcar, but there are still route details (beyond OTR) to be worked out, and my understanding is that the funding has not yet been fully assembled.  This could be a huge boost to economic development in the neighborhood. 

The experience in Portland, where a modern streetcar was introduced earlier this decade, has been that ridership has far exceeded expectations and that the service has been a major catalyst for nearby walkable development and reduced vehicle emissions.  Go here to watch enthusiastic Cincinnati developer-turned-advocate John Schneider (with whom I shared breakfast one morning) make a persuasive case for the Cincinnati streetcar.

In the next, concluding installment, we'll look at the progress so far and the prospects for making it green.

Kaid Benfield writes (almost) daily about community, development, and the environment.  For more posts, see his blog's home page. 

 

Share | | |

Comments

D R E WJun 8 2009 02:05 PM

thanks for this series on OTR and for exposing this amazing neighborhood to the world. not many people know what's in cincinnati and their ignorant misperceptions are usually washed away the minute they visit the city.

we also struggle with the local public's perception of OTR. many refuse to visit the neighborhood because they feel it's unsafe... a year ago, thanks to a major police sweep, it became the city's safest neighborhood.

but, still the local ignorance concerning the neighborhood continues. that's why i feel OTR, and cincinnati in general, would benefit from outsiders moving in to the city to renovate these amazing old buildings while bringing their new ideas and enthusiasm. a progressive idea the region has yet to embrace.

i really hope that preservation efforts can make significant headway in the coming years. thanks again for this series.

MikeJun 8 2009 03:14 PM

Thanks for the series. One over-looked asset of OTR is that it links the downtown business district with other key downtown areas. To the north there is the University of Cincinnati and the area's 7 hospitals. To the east there is Mount Adams and the growing business zone on Gilbert Ave.

Kaid @ NRDCJun 8 2009 09:33 PM

Thanks for the kind words. I learned a lot from my visit and the reading I've done since.

Adam RosaJun 9 2009 12:57 PM

This is a great first look at OTR. One thing to note... about 12 years ago, Cincy officials had the opportunity to build a new urban ballpark (Broadway Commons) on Central Parkway right at the edge of OTR next to the then burgeoning Main Street District. Instead, they made the boneheaded decision to "put it on the river" so that suburbanites could get to it right off of the highway.

If they had made the right decision, OTR would probably look a hell of a lot more like a more interesting version of LODO in Denver. Instead, much of the Main Street momentum dissipated in the wake of the riots in the early 2000s and the riverfront is covered with two hulking stadiums and a whole lot of surface parking.

D R E WJun 9 2009 06:41 PM

where to put the two stadiums was based more on who was/is managing the teams. they want their fans/patrons to come to their stadium hungry and thirsty to spend money on overpriced stadium food and beer. had the baseball stadium been in broadway commons, there'd be other bars, etc close by. it'd be competition for the ballpark. much of the delay concerning the banks is for the same reason. blame the reds and bengals management, not the city.

Kevin LeMasterJun 10 2009 09:06 AM

^ There's plenty of blame to go around with the City and county, too.

Great series, Kaid. I'm looking forward to Part 3!

Jim UberJun 10 2009 07:27 PM

Kaid thanks again for this series; I am eagerly looking forward to ideas about how to take advantage of OTR's natural street and block scale and architectural features to create a place where people can live sustainably without having to try so damn hard.

Thanks for the link to learn more about Old North St. Louis and will do just that.

I'm continually struck by how dumb I feel about how best to spend energy to change places like OTR. I mean, I listen to smart architects talk about "complete streets" and the like, and I'm often left with a feeling that it's so sad that we need to have such a major production for such commonsense ideas. The automobile is such a powerful force... but did we really get to the point where we _like_ this lifestyle? Or is the automobile a means to the best end "we" could come up with, in order to get away from people that aren't like us. Did excessive fear drive us to the automobile or did the automobile drive us to excess fear? So then I start to think less about architects, and want to talk more to sociologists instead.

Confused... but I don't think I'm alone.

Anyway, OTR doesn't need a complete streets program, it was built with one, by people who just wanted to get off a streetcar and have a beer at a nearby tavern on their way home. That's the good news. But Kaid's remarks that it will be critical to include existing residents at every step is on target. Hopefully that can happen, and that it will encourage a naturally healthy mix of new residents to follow.

Kaid @ NRDCJun 11 2009 02:34 PM

Thanks so much for reading and commenting.

Comments are closed for this post.

About

Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit NRDC.org.

Send Me Updates About: Kaid Benfield

As new content on your chosen topic gets posted, you'll receive an automated email via FeedBurner. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Feeds: Stay Plugged In

Feeds: Kaid Benfield’s blog