skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Clean Power plan
Safe Chemicals

John Walke’s Blog

Oppose the TRAIN Act, the Worst Air Pollution Bill Ever to Reach the House Floor

John Walke

Posted September 19, 2011

, , , , ,
Share | | |

The TRAIN Act (H.R. 2401)—the most deadly bill on House Majority Leader Eric Cantor’s Pollution Plan—is expected to be brought up for a House floor vote this Friday (9/23).

As initially introduced, the TRAIN Act was a biased and irresponsible “study” bill—creating a committee of cabinet members to review just the costs of a multitude of Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) health standards, while ignoring the greater health and monetary benefits to Americans. While this version of the bill would have been harmful to human health, the bill is now an entirely different, and much more deadly beast.

 Why would the current version of TRAIN result in so many more deaths and health hazards? The answer is an amendment from Rep. Whitfield (R-KY) added to the bill in Full Committee that could permanently block two life-saving clean air safeguards: the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule, which curbs smog and soot pollution from power plants that crosses state lines, and the Mercury and Air Toxics standards, which limit mercury and other toxic air pollution from power plants. It would do this by forbidding the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from re-issuing the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule for a minimum of 19 months, and any Mercury and Air Toxics standards for a minimum of 15 months. 

But the amendment does not stop there. It also eliminates any actual deadline for EPA to re-issue standards, repealing current law, which has imposed firm deadlines for EPA to issue air toxics standards for polluting industries ever since the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments. Thus, the TRAIN Act that passed out of the House Energy and Commerce Committee would allow these life-saving standards to be shelved indefinitely.

The health standards that the TRAIN Act will prevent are long overdue and would save tens of thousands of lives every year once they are implemented. I’ve blogged about how important the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule and Mercury and Air Toxics standards are here, here, here, here, and here. Blocking these standards for just one additional year would result in:

  • up to 25,300 lives lost;
  •  more than 11,000 heart attacks;
  • more than 120,000 asthma attacks;
  • over 12,200 more hospital and emergency room visits; and
  • many hundreds of thousands more days of missed work or school.

smokeytrain_Phil_NZsmall.JPGAnd the bill’s lengthier minimum periods of delay (15 & 19 months) would result in up to 33,450 premature deaths. The real toll likely will be much higher since the legislation allows indefinite delays in these vital public health safeguards.

While the initial version of the TRAIN Act was bad, the version the House is scheduled to vote on this week is indefensible. It will sacrifice tens of thousands of lives, pollute the air we breathe, and expose our children, families, and communities to toxic air pollutants that cause illness and developmental disorders. 


We urge you to call your Representative and urge them to vote “NO” on H.R. 2401 and block this reckless attack on clean air protections for all Americans. 

Photo by Phil Norton on Flickr

Share | | |


Kelly JackaonSep 20 2011 06:34 PM

Cantor and his crew are what is ruining America. They have no clue what Americans really want. They just play crude lip service to the idea of it and laugh at the public who stupidly trusted them enough to elect them. A horrible mistake not to be repeated next time.

Lisa WarmbrodtSep 20 2011 10:04 PM

Is it coincidence that Cantor's anti-EPA bill bears the same name as ALEC's (American Legislative Exchange Council) strategy for state legislators to do away with the EPA?

John ShovelierSep 20 2011 10:42 PM

Eric Cantor is an idiot. He works for corporation and not the people who voted for him. He's a racist, greedy SOB who need to be thrown out of office as soon as possible. He and McConnell are two of the worst politician whose taking money from the people who need it most. We need to throw them out on the street next election.

teri wellsSep 21 2011 03:00 PM

What is the TRAIN ACT? I'm sure it's something else to rip apart the earth for some corp. Where do these idiots in government and corp think they'll live after everythings destroyed? Is the moon available for high end real estate development so they can haul their treasures up and move in

Comments are closed for this post.


Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit

Feeds: John Walke’s blog

Feeds: Stay Plugged In