skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Fracking
Safe Chemicals
Defending the Clean Air Act

Jake Schmidt’s Blog

Brazilian Climate Change Plan...Pledge to Significant Cuts in Deforestation

Jake Schmidt

Posted December 12, 2008 in Saving Wildlife and Wild Places, Solving Global Warming

Tags:
, , , , , , ,
Share | | |

As I briefly discussed on Earthbeat, on Monday Brazilian President Lula da Silva signed a national climate change plan, which included a pledge to cut Brazil's deforestation rate in half from today's levels by 2018 -- from approximately 4,633 to 2,260 square miles (as discussed by Reuters).  [Note: It amounts to almost a 70% cut from the average annual rate from 1996-2005 of 7,502 sq. miles (19,000 sq. kilometers), which is the figure included in the report as Point Carbon sub req. reports.]    

The reduction in deforestation is to be reduced in stages over defined four year periods through 2017:

  • From 2006-2009, deforestation is to be cut to 4,402 sq. miles (11,400 sq. km) -- a 40% cut below the 10-year average used in the plan;
  • 2010-2013, a cut to 3,081 sq. miles (7,980 sq. km) -- an additional 30% reduction from the previous four years; and
  • 2014-2017, a reduction to 2,157 sq. miles (5,586 sq. km) -- an additional 30% reduction from the previous four years.

Now that is a significant cut in deforestation rates if achieved (see figure which shows the target as the red dashed line and the actual annual rates in black), especially compared with the high rate in 2004.

Brazilian Deforestation Targets

The early years require essentially no improvement from today's levels (the target through 2009 is roughly the same as the actual 2007 rate).  So, it essentially amounts to stabilizing deforestation rates this year and next at last year's levels.  But, they'll need to reverse the current trend as recent estimates show that the deforestation rate is on the rise.

If the annual cut in the final years of the plan -- 2,394 sq. miles per year -- are continued for subsequent four year periods (a proposition not included in the plan), deforestation in Brazil could end sometime after 2025.  Sounds like an objective worth shooting for, if not sooner.

There is always room to criticize that this plan: isn't aggressive enough, should be faster, much of the real effort occurs after President Lula da Silva is out of office, and still leaves a lot of deforestation at the end -- all fair criticisms (see: Mongabay.com article on the plan and their story on World Wildlife Fund's critiques).  We definitely need to work to improve this strategy (e.g., by reducing the rate further and faster) and ensure that the proper laws, programs, etc. are established on the ground to actually deliver this goal. 

It does, however, mark a very significant shift for Brazil.  They have long argued against establishing targets to reduce their deforestation emissions so any target is definitely a huge step forward in the decades long battle to address deforestation. 

And, since deforestation accounts for the majority of Brazil's estimated global warming pollution it potentially marks a major national effort to reduce their emissions.  Of course, if achieved.  According to one estimate it could achieve a total reduction in emissions of 4.8 billion tons of CO2 (Point Carbon sub req. reports) -- an amount equal to the European Union's total current emissions.  

While that is still a lot of deforestation -- too much in many respects -- it is a potentially groundbreaking action if they can meet it. 

Of course, the crucial test will be if the government puts in place the necessary policies to achieve these commitments.  Their success in addressing deforestation has been a mixed bag of late (as I discussed here), so it will require a sustained effort over many years and real actions on-the-ground.  And political support that continues beyond the current Administration, as much of the really steep declines occur after President Lula is out of office.

So an opening has emerged in Brazil's position on global warming (and deforestation emissions in particular) as we head into the crucial debate next year on the shape of global efforts to address deforestation emissions.  Positive signs from Poland that can help build some momentum next year as we lead-in to Copenhagen.

Share | | |

Comments

S. Jacob ScherrDec 12 2008 10:44 AM

As I read Jake's commentary on Brazil's commendable commitment to reduce its rate of deforestation over the next decade, I was reminded of the words of a former Canadian Environmental Minister who said that "politicians like nothing better than making promises for which they will not be held accountable." As Jake points out, much of the heavy lifting to reverse the current deforestation trend will take place after the current Brazilian President leaves office. Also it is easy to set targets for reductions particularly far off in the future. We need to insist that nations go beyond just making pledges for emission reductions to describe what concrete policy measures they will be adopting to bring about those reductions.

Jake SchmidtDec 15 2008 12:22 PM

It is definitely important that we transition from "words" to "deeds". Clearly, success in addressing deforestation in Brazil will require more than a declaration from President Lula. It will require actions on the ground.

It is definitely too bad that they didn't commit to more progress while President Lula is in office.

So, we'll have to wait and see. All eyes will now be focused on Brazil's ensuing actions.

Comments are closed for this post.

About

Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit NRDC.org.

Feeds: Jake Schmidt’s blog

Feeds: Stay Plugged In