skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Clean Power plan
Safe Chemicals

Frances Beinecke’s Blog

The Joys of Sport Fishing Deepen in Healthier Oceans

Frances Beinecke

Posted September 9, 2010

, , , , , , , ,
Share | | |

Some people assume that environmentalists and sport fishermen cannot see eye to eye when it comes to protecting the oceans. I know this is not the case, because I count myself a member of both groups.

I have fished ever since I was a girl. My father took me and my siblings fishing for striped bass and bluefish on Cape Cod each and every summer when I was a young girl.

I joined my college fishing team and that brought me to the waters off Nova Scotia. Since those early days, I have fished off Florida, in the Caribbean, and even the Indian Ocean.

I also like to fly fish the cold rivers of Montana and Idaho and the clear lakes and ponds around my family’s home in the Adirondacks.

I am well acquainted with the thrill of feeling the tug on the line. I am also aware of the enthusiasm sport fishermen have for the sea.

Most of us want to share the same pleasures with our children and grandchildren—the way my father did when he introduced me to fishing. But as we think about the long-term future of the sport, we have to figure out how to maintain a healthy marine environment so other generations can experience these joys as well.

Because let’s face it. Things have changed since I started fishing as a girl. Back then, 70,000 people lived on Cape Cod; now it has a year-round population of 230,000 and tens of thousands more visitors in the summer.

Many more pressures are bearing down on coastal waters these days, from water quality problems to destructive commercial fishing practices. To keep our oceans healthy—and sport fishing vibrant—in the face of these pressures, we need active, thoughtful management.

We support marine protected areas as a part of sound management because they help safeguard the health of the ocean. Research shows that, with careful design, marine protected areas can contribute to healthy oceans: they harbor more and bigger fish, more resilient habitat, and more diverse life than unprotected areas. Many scientists also believe that marine protected areas are good for sport fishing.

Yet some groups have opposed the creation of marine protected areas, pitting sport fishermen and environmental groups against one another. For example, Shimano, the fishing gear and bike-part manufacturer, has sought to postpone or suspend implementation of California’s popular Marine Life Protection Act.

We greatly value our alliances with recreational fishermen in fighting for clean water, restoring salmon habitat and working for sustainable fishery management. NRDC and Shimano, along with other recreational fishing interests, have agreed to meet to discuss our different perspectives. We look forward to that.

After all, we share a goal: keeping oceans healthy and fish abundant. We may not always have the same vision of how to achieve that goal, but we hope to find common cause—starting with the pleasure of sitting out on the open water, waiting to catch a big one.

Share | | |


Jeff KoenigsburgerSep 11 2010 02:46 AM

We are not interested in any sweet stories as your policies are breaking up families and causing a net loss of jobs. Just make sure that your science is credible, unbiased and will withstand the test of a peer review.

Gordon RobertsonSep 12 2010 12:58 PM

Let me be perfectly clear. The sportfishing industry and California angling organizations asked to “…postpone or suspend implementation of California’s popular Marine Life Protection Act.” The request was made not by Shimano but by the many members of the sportfishing community in CA and beyond. While Shimano is a member of the American Sportfishing Association, it is only one of hundreds of industry members who have asked that the MLPA process in CA be objective, science driven, fairly implemented and not driven by arbitrary political deadlines. Your readers should know that the sportfishing industry and angler organizations in CA have supported closures in each phase of the CA MLPA process. When there is disagreement between the sportfishing community and the environmental community it does not foster further communications or alliances to single out a company in the sportfishing community who has done nothing but be a good corporate citizen.

Gordon Robertson, Vice President, American Sportfishing Association

Comments are closed for this post.


Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit

Feeds: Frances Beinecke’s blog

Feeds: Stay Plugged In