skip to main content

→ Top Stories:
Keystone XL Pipeline
Defending the Clean Air Act

Adrianna Quintero’s Blog

New Cuban Crisis Threatens Florida's Coasts

Adrianna Quintero

Posted February 3, 2012 in Curbing Pollution, Moving Beyond Oil

Tags:
, , , , , ,
Share | | |

Ever since Cuba’s intent to drill within 70 miles of Florida’s coast has become known, concerned Floridians have been reeling with how to protect our treasured Florida Keys. For many Floridians, this is a very charged issue. It’s no secret that having Cuba drill for oil is itself a hugely political issue-- exiles and many others outraged at Cuba potentially developing significant oil resources. Add to that the fact that a spill in the area would seriously endanger one of the country’s most sensitive ecosystems, (and an economic engine for Florida tourism) and you have a firestorm.

This would not be the first time that oil could generate a windfall for a dictator. We have been enriching unstable governments for years due to our deadly addiction to oil. But so far, our consumptive dependence on oil has only prompted us to deal with threats to our national energy security from our oil “dealer’s” threats to increase prices, block the Strait of Hormuz, and manipulate markets knowing we’re at their mercy. In this case, the oil producer is also a neighbor and the risk to the iconic Florida Keys has truly brought the threat home.

The Keys are known as the recreational fishing and scuba diving capital of the world. Extensive coral reefs on the coast of the Gulf of Mexico in Florida are home to some of the world’s most diverse ecosystems, mangroves, sea grass, coral reefs and marine life and the related tourism it generates is no small sum. In 2010, Florida welcomed 82.3 million visitors who spent more than $62.7 billion; and the industry provided employment to nearly a million residents. Each year, Florida generates more than $37.3 billion and 452,811 jobs to Florida's economy on fisheries, wildlife, and activities carried out in its waters.

We all suffered through the tragic disaster of BP’s Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010. Theroil pelican.JPGe was no global precedent to guide the emergency response at such depth and no one could have imagined the economic and environmental consequences that recklessly drilling 5,500 feet deep would cause. Now, this drilling platform, the Scarabeo 9 is poised to drill deeper yet, and the plan in the event of a spill or explosion, is completely out of our hands.price of our oil dependence and precisely why we need to stop drilling pristine places.

We need great political will to pave the way towards a clean energy future and sometimes fear can be a great motivator. In this case, fear that Cuban oil development would result in Cuba becoming an oil producing country or causing a spill that would pollute our beloved backyard has motivated some who generally don’t recognize the environmental toll of drilling, to speak out against it. It has also resulted in a bipartisan group of legislators including Bill Nelson and Marco Rubio to introduce a bill in the Senate (S. 1836), and David Rivera (R-FL) along with a group of 16 bipartisan co-sponsors to do the same in the House (H.R. 3393) calling for penalties on oil spills-- without limitations.

The risks of drilling are real and not limited to drilling done by countries who we don’t play well with. Yes, the dangers of a spill in Cuba are real and out of four hands, but even where U.S. drilling is concerned, the president’s National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling concluded the oil industry lacked the kind of safety culture that could prevent another disaster. And even here, the government lacks the authority and resources necessary to police the industry. We cannot waste another opportunity to take measures to ensure the safety and well being of our communities by holding polluters and policy makers accountable.

Let’s not wait for the next disaster. We must make an effort to wean ourselves from oil now or continue to face big risks and deal with situations like these where dictators are all too ready to become the next “oil dealer” eager to feed our dirty oil addiction.

It’s time to call on our leaders in Congress to protect special places from drilling, protect our oceans, adopt adequate penalties, and most importantly, to support a swift transition to a clean and vibrant energy future.

Share | | |

Comments

Walter LippmannFeb 4 2012 01:23 AM

Cuba has never had an oil spill. Cuba's tourism industry would take a terrible hit if it did, so Cuba has a high incentive to do everything it can to prevent an oil spill.

The US has had more than its share of oil spills so who is Washington to threaten to punish Cuba for doign exactly what is done in the United States: exploiting a natural resource?

Sure, we in the United States should wean ourselves off of cars and other such unstainable transportation methodologies, but it's time we learned to live with and cooperate with our next-door neighbor, just ninety miles away.

Rubio and his gang of anti-Castro militants don't want to cooperate with Cuba, they want to prevent Cuba from developing this or any other souce of indepenence.

It's time and overtime to normalize relations with our Caribbean neighbor!

Robert RFeb 4 2012 02:28 AM

Adriana, it is time you educated yourself a bit mre about Cuba. Cuba is no more a dictatorship than several other of the countries the USA routinely does business with, such as China, vietnam and Lao PDR. Interestingly enough, if you consult the US State Department Notes, I think you will find that Cuba is the sole remaining dictatorship among soverreign nations. Why might that be? My opinion is that it is a cold war legacy that is looking very uncharmingly retro in these times.

Cuba, like many other nations the USA does business with, is a socialist state. If you check around the internet, I believe you will find that Cuba is the only state, socialist or capitalist or monarchical-despotic, that lives within its ecological footprint.

Your so-called "Cuban dictatorship" has a number of creditable achievements to advertise. Excellent, free medical care, which have led to the best world health statistcs of any Latin American country. Free and universal education, and no student loans to pay back.

If all you ever hear about Cuba comes from bloggers who are still living in the last century, than you are doing yourself a disservice.

Two questions:
(1) Do you have the time to read some selections an Autobiography of Fidel Castro?

I ask because I found the book at the Melbourne Airport and hugely enjoyed it, and decided I should educate mysellf about Cuba.
http://bit.ly/xgK2rp
(2) Will you consider a more sensible title for your article?

I ask because it implies that Cuba is in a state of crisis, which is not the case to my knowledge.

Thank you for your consideration.

Joe ConchyFeb 4 2012 12:20 PM

Quintero is the name of two brands of premium cigar, one produced on the island of Cuba. Are Cuban exiles using the environment argument to promote a political point of view?

Laura CanevariFeb 6 2012 10:56 AM

This is such a NIMBY hypocritical argument and I totally agree with Walter Lippmann on his claims! Cuba does not want an oil spill more than the US would. Yet they have the right to develop their oil reserves if they want to. If that causes a threat to Florida's 'lovely beaches, so be it! Is not like the US has ever set an example in environmental protection or in marine stewardship anyways...

if you are going to "call on our leaders in Congress to protect special places from drilling, protect our oceans, adopt adequate penalties, and most importantly, to support a swift transition to a clean and vibrant energy future" you should really start doing so in your own back yard before you dare setting obligations on other nations...

Also your characterization of Cuba as a threat to the US is full of historical bias. Their standards would not be any less than those of any US oil company (they are after all set by international bodies)!

Adrianna QuinteroFeb 6 2012 12:00 PM

Thank you all for your comments. As I said, this is a charged political issue and I agree that we need to start here in the US and move beyond oil.
I do hope that all of the commenters who have such faith in Cuba's ability to control a spill are correct, though seeing the failure to effectively limit the BP spill in the US makes me think this confidence is misplaced. Whether we like it or not (and regardless of who's to blame for this) Cuba has less resources to respond to a spill and if the US with it's unlimited resources spent close to 100 days and billions of dollars stopping the flow of oil in the Gulf, a spill is a serious concern. Just ask any of the fishermen who lost it all waiting and worrying about their livelihood.
As for Cuba itself, it is indeed a beautiful place with wonderful people (and no I am not Cuban - nor heiress to a cigar fortune!) and I for one do hope they keep the importance of their beaches in mind in putting in place safety measures (after all--Gulf beaches are also amazing and a great source of tourism and that hasn't stopped drilling accidents there). However, it is a fact that Cuba continues to violate human rights and individual freedom of expression in ways that would easily land any of us in jail if the government decided our comments were out of line. Cuban is still regarded as a totalitarian regime and as such their decisions around drilling are at bext a question mark. One that could potentially threaten a treasured place and thousands of jobs.

Comments are closed for this post.

About

Switchboard is the staff blog of the Natural Resources Defense Council, the nation’s most effective environmental group. For more about our work, including in-depth policy documents, action alerts and ways you can contribute, visit NRDC.org.

Feeds: Adrianna Quintero’s blog

Feeds: Stay Plugged In